Top 10 Reasons a Judge Will Change Custody in California (2025)

Although court orders have the effect of finality, certain types of family law orders can be modified if the petitioning party demonstrates that a modification is justified and serves the interests of the child. If you are considering requesting or fighting a custody modification, it is well worth knowing the top 10 reasons a judge will change custody in California.

1. Parental Alienation
   If one parent actively attempts to harm the child’s relationship with the other parent, the court views this behavior negatively. Documented parental alienation can support a change in custody to protect the child’s emotional well-being.
2. Relocation by a Parent
   A move to another state or distant location can disrupt established custody and visitation schedules. Between 2022 and 2023, approximately 690,100 people moved out of California, making relocation a common custody issue. Courts closely review move-away requests and their impact on the child’s relationships.
3. Substance Use
   When one parent has a substance use problem, that can put the child’s safety at risk. One remedy could involve modifying the custody order or suspending the rights of the parent until they demonstrate that they have recovered fully from their addiction.
4. Abuse or Neglect
   Child abuse and neglect are serious allegations that the courts can act on. If there is evidence of physical or emotional abuse or neglect, the courts can issue emergency orders that prioritize the child’s safety. An example of neglect could include one parent failing to ensure their child is properly fed and bathed.
5. Changes in Living Conditions
   Significant changes in housing, such as an unstable or unsafe home environment or frequent moves, can support a modification request. The courts want to see that children have as safe and stable a home environment as possible.
6. Health Issues
   A major decline in one parent’s physical or mental health can also necessitate court intervention. Health issues related to the child can also be a consideration if one parent is unable or unwilling to provide the time and resources needed to manage their child’s health condition or disability.
7. Educational Needs
   If a parent cannot meet the child’s educational needs or actively interferes with schooling, courts may intervene. Judges often take steps to ensure children have the support necessary for academic success.
8. Violations of Court Orders
   Repeated violations of court orders or visitation agreements show a lack of respect for the court’s authority, the child’s well-being, and the parental rights of the other parent. Consistent noncompliance can justify a change in custody.
9. New Family Dynamics
   The introduction of new partners, siblings, and stepfamilies can alter the child’s home environment. In some cases, a new boyfriend or girlfriend who has a criminal record or other reason for concern could justify a request for custody modification.
10. Voluntary Requests for Modification by Both Parents
    There may be times when both parents are in agreement about the need to modify a custody order. One example may be a parent who has to move away and can no longer maintain the visitation schedule. If both parents are in agreement and the arrangement serves the interest of the child, the order can be modified.

Understanding the Statistics Driving Modification Requests

There were 114,238 marital filings (dissolutions, legal separations, and nullities) in fiscal year 2020-2021. California’s divorce rate is approximately 6.9 per 1,000 women aged 15 and older, highlighting how often custody decisions arise.

California courts take custody modifications seriously. As of 2022, about 15,349 children in California were waiting to be adopted, with 8,180 of them already having had their biological parents’ rights terminated. In fiscal year 2022, California finalized 5,657 adoptions from foster care.

FAQs

What Is Considered a Change in Circumstances?

A change in circumstances is a significant shift affecting the child’s well-being or living situation. Common examples include a parent’s relocation, changes in work schedule, substance abuse, domestic violence, or failure to meet the child’s needs. Filing a motion to modify custody requires proving that the change impacts the child’s best interests. Judges require strong, current evidence supporting the petitioner’s request before modifying existing custody orders.

At What Age Can a Child Decide Which Parent They Want to Live With in California?

In California, children aged 14 and older may express a custodial preference in court, but their wishes are not automatically granted. Judges must consider the child’s maturity and reasoning. The court always evaluates whether the child’s choice aligns with their best interests. File a request for judicial consideration if the child’s preference becomes a relevant issue during a custody modification proceeding.

What Should You Avoid Saying During a Custody Battle in California?

Avoid making negative statements about the other parent, false allegations, or emotional outbursts during a custody battle. Openly criticizing the other parent can damage your credibility. Focus on presenting facts that show how your requested custody plan serves the child’s best interests. Remain professional, stick to documented evidence, and comply fully with court expectations to strengthen your position during hearings.

Is California a 50/50 Custody State?

California is not necessarily a 50/50 custody state. The law favors frequent and continuing contact with both parents, but 50/50 custody is not automatically guaranteed. Judges base custody decisions on the child’s best interests, not a default formula. Parents can agree to equal time-sharing, or courts may order it if appropriate. File a custody modification request with clear evidence if seeking to change an existing parenting schedule to a 50/50 arrangement.

Protect Your Child’s Best Interests With Quinn & Dworakowski, LLP

Life changes can significantly impact existing custody arrangements. Whether due to relocation, changes in a parent’s stability, or the evolving needs of the child, courts in California prioritize the child’s well-being when reviewing modification requests. Preparing a strong case is essential to securing an arrangement that protects your relationship with your child.

At Quinn & Dworakowski, LLP, our experienced family law attorneys are ready to guide you through the custody modification process. We can tailor our strategies to your goals while keeping your child’s best interests as the central focus. Contact our office today to schedule a consultation.

About The Author

Stephane Quinn

Attorney Stephane Quinn is an experienced divorce and family law attorney and Certified Family Law Specialist (California Bar Board of Legal Specialization). As founding partner of Quinn & Dworakowski, LLP, he focuses on fathers' rights, complex custody cases, and high-asset divorces. Admitted to the California Bar in 2010 (SBN #278188), he has been recognized as: Super Lawyers Rising Star (Since 2017) Cum laude graduate from California State University, Long Beach Juris Doctor from Fowler School of Law in Orange Fluent in French, Attorney Quinn aggressively protects clients' rights in Orange County family courts.

View all posts by Stephane Quinn →